The visible and hidden annual costs of paper forms at a shire council
Iceberg slide that shows the cost the budget does not name
An iceberg slide shows that the part of a problem people can see is the smallest part, with the larger causes or costs sitting out of view. This one shows Elderbrook Shire Council, a fictional council, that its $18,400 printing line hides a paper forms bill of $174,000 a year.
What is on the slide
- Eyebrow
- Hidden Costs
- Headline
- Paper Forms Cost $174,000 a Year
- Above the waterline
- Printing, $18,400: paper, toner and print contracts for 212 council forms, the only line the Elderbrook Shire budget names.
- 01 Data Entry, $96,000
- Two full time staff retype about 41,000 paper forms a year into the property and permit systems.
- 02 Corrections, $37,500
- One form in six comes back with a missing field, which costs a phone call, a letter and a second round of entry.
- 03 Storage, $22,100
- Seven years of signed originals held in an offsite archive, plus a retrieval fee whenever a record is requested.
When this is the right slide
Right when an audience is judging a problem by the one cost or symptom it can see, and you can name and price the larger layers sitting underneath it.
What to swap it for
Metrics: Hero Stat + Narrative. When the audience already accepts the hidden costs and only needs the $174,000 total with a short case for acting.
What this slide shows
A small eyebrow reads Hidden Costs above the headline Paper Forms Cost $174,000 a Year, centred on a pale surface band. A white card floats in that band, labelled What the Budget Shows, with the heading Printing, $18,400 and the line: paper, toner and print contracts for 212 council forms, the only line the Elderbrook Shire budget names. A brand coloured waterline divides the slide. Below it, a dark water band is labelled Below the Waterline and holds three numbered rows. 01 Data Entry, $96,000: two full time staff retype about 41,000 paper forms a year. 02 Corrections, $37,500: one form in six comes back with a missing field. 03 Storage, $22,100: seven years of originals in an offsite archive, plus retrieval fees. The numbers in the four costs add up exactly to the headline, and the slide carries no chart or icon. The image of the waterline does the visual work, and the figures do the persuading.
When this is the right slide
Use an iceberg slide when the audience is judging something by its most visible part and the real weight lies elsewhere. Hidden cost cases, culture and behaviour talks, risk briefings and technical debt discussions all fit. It works when you can name the hidden layers and give each one evidence, ideally a number. It is the wrong slide when the hidden part is smaller than the visible part, when you cannot quantify the layers, or when the audience is hostile to metaphors. A finance committee may prefer the same four numbers in a plain table, and that is a better choice for a written report. The metaphor also helps a presenter who has to deliver unwelcome news. Starting from a cost the audience owns, then descending layer by layer, lets people discover the larger figure for themselves rather than being told their budget was wrong.
How to adapt it
First, change the visible card to whatever your audience currently sees and accepts, such as licence fees for a software decision, and keep its number. Second, replace the three hidden layers with your own causes, each with a figure and a one sentence explanation, ordered from shallow to deep. Third, when the audience already accepts that the costs exist and only needs the total, swap to the hero stat with narrative layout, put $174,000 in large type and use the narrative beside it to say what the council could do with the saving. Whichever version you choose, keep the sources for each figure ready in an appendix or the speaker notes. Council members will ask where the 41,000 forms and the one in six correction rate came from, and a quick answer keeps the discussion on the decision. Round figures only where the audience would round them; a council reading $96,000 trusts it more than $95,872.40, but the total must still match the layers exactly.
What makes this slide work
The visible card is the number they already know
Printing, $18,400 sits in a white card above the waterline with the line: the only line the Elderbrook Shire budget names. Starting from a figure councillors already accept gives the slide credibility, because the audience agrees with the first claim before the hidden layers start to change their view.
Every hidden layer carries a dollar figure
Data Entry, $96,000. Corrections, $37,500. Storage, $22,100. Each row below the waterline states its cost in the heading and its cause in one sentence, such as one form in six coming back with a missing field. The metaphor is backed by numbers that can be checked against payroll and contracts.
The headline adds it up
Paper Forms Cost $174,000 a Year is the sum of the four figures on the slide: $18,400 plus $96,000 plus $37,500 plus $22,100. The total reconciles exactly, so the audience can trust it, and putting it in the headline means the point lands even for someone who only reads the title.
Questions people ask
What are the limits of the iceberg metaphor on a slide?
It implies the hidden part is always bigger and that nobody could see it, which is not always true. Here the hidden costs really are larger, $155,600 against $18,400, so the picture is honest. Do not use an iceberg when the hidden items are small or already well known; the audience will notice the metaphor is doing the arguing.
How many hidden layers should an iceberg slide show?
Three, as this layout does. One visible item against three hidden ones makes the ratio the story. Five or more layers turns the water band into a list and loses the image. If there are more hidden costs, group them; data entry and rekeying, for example, belong together.
Should the hidden layers be ordered by size?
Order them by depth of visibility rather than size: the first row is nearest the surface and easiest to see, the last is the deepest. Here data entry is a cost staff feel daily, corrections are noticed now and then, and archive storage is almost invisible. That ordering also happens to run from largest to smallest, which reads well.
Where does the total go on an iceberg slide?
In the headline. Paper Forms Cost $174,000 a Year tells the audience the sum before they add up the layers, and every figure on the slide reconciles to it. If the headline only described the metaphor, people would spend the slide doing arithmetic instead of listening to what the council should do next.
When should an iceberg slide be followed by a second slide?
When the decision needs the saving, not just the cost. Follow this slide with one that shows the total and what a digital process would cost instead, so the council sees the gap. The iceberg sets up the problem; the next slide should carry the proposal and the number that justifies it.
How do I present an iceberg slide to a council or board?
Start above the waterline with the number they already know, $18,400 for printing, and agree on it. Then go down one layer at a time, giving each a fact they can check, such as 41,000 forms retyped by two staff. Finish on the headline total and stop. Let the gap between the first number and the last sink in.
Build your own in about a minute
The button below opens the generator with this use case already described. Change the wording to match your own, generate, then edit anything you like.
Make one like thisOther slide examples
Title and bullets slide where every bullet is a full claim
A title and bullets slide lists a handful of separate points under one heading, and it works only when each bullet is a complete, short claim the reader can take in at a glance. This one sets out seven changes in version 4.2 of Rostrel, a fictional rostering app.
Learning objectives slide with outcomes a trainer can assess
A learning objectives slide tells participants at the start of a session what they will be able to do by the end, written so that each outcome can be observed and assessed. This one opens a two hour safe lifting course for crews at Kettlewick Removals, a fictional moving company.
Do and don't slide with a sample line for every rule
A do and don't slide teaches a standard by pairing each rule with its opposite, so the reader learns what good looks like and what to avoid in the same glance. This one sets the brand voice for Marrowbank Landcare, a fictional community landcare charity, with a sample line on each side.
Want the steps in the builder? Read Style text and add callouts, stats and lists, then Present your slides with speaker notes and a pen. For everything this generator can do, see the slide maker.
Written and checked by the OneCraft team. Last checked .