Websites

Membership site pricing: what the platform takes and what members pay

Membership site pricing has two halves: what the platform charges you, as a plan, a percentage of member payments or both, and what you charge members. On 50 members paying $15 a month, the platform's share ranges from about $23 to $179 a month across nine plans on seven platforms checked on 20 October 2026, before card processing.

· Co-founder

4 min read · Published

Membership site pricing is two decisions: which platform fee model you accept, and what price you set for members. The platform side is either a flat monthly plan, a percentage of every member payment, or both. On a small membership of 50 people paying $15 a month, those models produce very different bills, from about $23 to $179 a month in the table below, before any card processing.

Every platform price below comes from its own pricing page, checked on 20 October 2026. If you are still deciding what a membership site is and what it holds, start with what a membership site is.

The three fee models

Percentage only. Patreon is free to start and takes 10% of what you earn, plus processing, currency conversion and payout fees. Nothing is due until members pay, which makes it the safest way to test an idea.

Plan plus percentage. Memberful Standard is $49 a month plus a 4.9% transaction fee. Teachable Starter is $39 a month plus 7.5%. Mighty Networks Launch is $79 a month plus 2%, and Circle Professional is $89 a month on annual billing plus 2%. These suit memberships big enough to cover the plan, with a percentage that keeps growing with you.

Plan, with no platform percentage. Teachable Builder at $89 a month lists a 0% transaction fee, and Kajabi Basic at $179 a month billed monthly charges card processing through Kajabi Payments rather than a separate platform percentage. These cost the most at the start and the least as revenue grows.

Where the lines cross

Plot your expected monthly revenue against each model and the best choice changes as you grow. At $750 a month, Patreon’s 10% is $75, cheaper than most plans. At $3,000 a month, the same 10% is $300, while Teachable Builder is still $89 and Mighty Networks Launch is $79 plus $60. The point where a flat plan becomes cheaper than a percentage is simply the plan price divided by the percentage you would otherwise pay: $89 divided by 10% is $890 a month.

Setting the member price

Platform fees are the smaller decision. The member price decides whether the membership works at all. Three things help:

  1. Anchor to an outcome. Price against what a member gets: a skill, a saved hour a week, a group they cannot find elsewhere. Mighty Networks reports an average monthly price of $48 across memberships sold by its hosts, and suggests starting with a paid challenge priced at $19 to $49.
  2. Offer two tiers at most to begin. A free tier to join and one paid tier is easy to explain. Add a higher tier once members ask for more.
  3. Offer a yearly price. Two months free on a yearly plan is common, and it improves cash flow.

Then work backwards from your costs. If the platform share, card fees and your own time cost $200 a month, you need 14 members at $15 just to break even.

Price for the members who leave

Every membership loses people each month, and the price has to carry that. If a few members cancel every month, you need new ones just to stand still, and the cost of finding them belongs in your sums. Three habits keep cancellations down more than a lower price does: a clear welcome that shows a new member where to start, something new every week or month so the membership feels alive, and an easy way to pause instead of cancel. Track how many members you start and end each month with from the first month, so you can tell whether a price change helped or hurt.

A membership on your own website

The last two rows of the table are a different route. On OneCraft an AI agent writes the website, and its memberships guide builds paid tiers as rows of a plans table, a free tier people join, courses and lessons gated by tier, and an account page with Manage billing. Members pay through Stripe Checkout as a direct charge on your own Stripe account, with OneCraft’s platform fee of 2% on Starter, 1% on Pro or 0.5% on Pro+, and Stripe’s own fees on top. A members feed with posts, groups and moderation comes from its community guide.

The plan price is lower, and the trade is features. There is no hosted video, no certificates and no live streaming, and email is limited to a newsletter of up to 500 confirmed subscribers per send. Every plan includes a hosted site database, or you can connect your own Supabase project. The Kajabi alternative and Teachable alternative pages set out what you give up.

A quick checklist before you launch

Membership platform fees from each platform's pricing page, checked 20 October 2026, and the platform's share on 50 members at $15 a month ($750), before card processing
Platform and planPlan priceFee on member paymentsPlatform share on $750 a month
PatreonFree to start10% of the income you earn, plus processing, conversion and payout fees$75
Memberful Standard$49 a month4.9% transaction fee$85.75
Teachable Starter$39 a month billed monthly7.5% transaction fee$95.25
Teachable Builder$89 a month billed monthly0% transaction fee$89
Mighty Networks Launch$79 a month2% transaction fee$94
Circle Professional$89 a month on annual billing2% transaction fee$104
Kajabi Basic$179 a month billed monthlyCard processing through Kajabi Payments, no separate platform percentage$179
OneCraft Starter, hosted database$8 a month2% platform fee, Stripe fees on top$23
OneCraft Pro, hosted database$25 a month1% platform fee, Stripe fees on top$32.50

Questions people ask

How much should I charge for a membership?

Start from the value of one result a member gets, not from what competitors charge. Mighty Networks says the average monthly price of memberships sold by its hosts is $48, which shows people pay real money for a community that delivers something. Test a price with your first 10 to 20 members before announcing it widely.

Is a percentage fee or a flat plan cheaper?

A percentage is cheaper while you are small and a flat plan is cheaper once you grow. Patreon's 10% is $75 on $750 a month but $750 on $7,500, while a flat plan stays the same. Work out the revenue where the two lines cross for the platforms you are considering.

Should I offer an annual membership?

An annual option paid upfront improves cash flow and reduces monthly cancellations, usually in exchange for a discount of one or two months. Offer it next to the monthly price so members can compare. Check that your platform supports yearly billing; OneCraft plans tables take a month or year interval.

What is a free tier for?

A free tier lets people join and see the community or a sample lesson before paying, which gives you an audience to convert. Keep something clearly better behind the paid tier, such as full courses, the members feed or events, and remind free members of it without nagging.

Do card fees come on top of platform fees?

Usually yes. Card processing is charged by the payment processor on each transaction, typically a percentage plus a fixed amount, on top of any platform percentage. Only some platforms bundle it into their own payment rate, so read each pricing page for the words processing and payout.

Can I change my membership price later?

Yes, but treat existing members carefully. A common approach is to raise the price for new members and keep current members on their original price for a set time. Tell members in advance and explain what the extra money pays for, since a surprise increase is a common reason people cancel.

Written by

Indunil Asanka · Co-founder

Builds the generation pipelines behind OneCraft: the slide, flyer and poster layout engines, the document grid and the render workers that turn a written brief into a finished file.

LinkedIn profile

Sources

Written and checked by the OneCraft team. Last checked .

Make your own website

Describe what you need and the generator writes and designs it, then you edit anything you like.

See what it can make

Not ready to start? See the AI website builder page first.

Read next